Update on Gordhan arrest 16 May 2016

Update on Gordhan arrest
It should be noted that the outrage of the Presidency and Shaun Abrahams head of the NPA over the Sunday Times report relates to the question of whether an arrest is “imminent”. They deny that but Abrahams confirms that he has been given a docket and sent it back for further work and he cannot confirm or deny whether Gordhan is a suspect. In other words, the Hawks, being rather eager to please Zuma and get rid of the Treasury people, may have presented a mishmash of evidence that is not easy to prosecute. NPA cannot work on that. So it is by no means over.

That is not to say that they can successfully prosecute Gordhan or anyone else in relation to the ‘rogue unit’ that never existed. The Sunday Times was fed information about this alleged unit but has in recent times fully recanted on that story and admitted that it was not ethical journalism. The Press Ombud had already found that to be the case. It will be hard to prove that Gordhan or others involved in the SARS at the time acted illegally.

The NPA is engaged in a lot of legal actions that are politically problematic but also unsuccessful. It has been rapped over the knuckles over prosecuting Booysen in KZN under Nomgciba Jiba (one of the bases for the bar council moving for her to be disciplined) but now he has been re-charged with substantially the same charges as before, under Abrahams.

This is part of a broader attack on the functioning of law enforcement agencies where they manifest professionalism and integrity. Charges or suspensions against others considered problematic like General Sibiya and Robert McBride have been thrown out or are still being contested. There is hardly an institution where there is optimal functionality, due to the political reasons for removing people.

Fragile democracy 15 May 2016

Fragile democracy
This morning the Sunday Times carried a lead story to the effect that Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan was about to be arrested and prosecuted for espionage, in relation to the discredited claim that a ‘rogue unit’ had been established in SARS. I and many others on social media believed the report but the Presidency denied it. At this point (Sunday evening) the Sunday Times has not said whether it stands by its story but it has also not withdrawn the claims
What is significant is that so many of us were willing to believe what may well be true, albeit delayed for now. We have come to expect cavalier treatment of legality that one can hold a key government position and them be arrested on flimsy charges the next day. That is the SA that we now live in under Zuma, a lawless state, with virtually every law enforcement agency compromised or under attack. The sooner we can find ways of restoring constitutional democracy the better for all of us.

Democracy beyond electoralism (Polity)


Raymond Suttner: Will Zuma go to jail? (Polity)


Raymond Suttner: The ANC ‘after Zuma’ (Polity)


Raymond Suttner: Scandals and betrayal in South Africa today (Polity)


Raymond Suttner: Bashir: South African government flouts international obligations and undermines freedom under the law


Raymond Suttner: Self-respect: the hidden costs of Nkandla


Launch of Recovering Democracy in SA at Book Lounge Cape Town, with Rebecca Davis, 9 April 2015 (photographs)


Raymond Suttner: ‘Party loyalty’, patronage and the future of SA parliament (The Con)


Eskom disarray and wider crisis of irregularity: how do we recover the promise of 1994?


Raymond Suttner: South African parliament now and in the future (Heinrich Boll foundation)


Recovering Democracy in SA (Polity interview)

Raymond Suttner: South Africa 20 years on: a state in crisis (The Africa Report)


Raymond Suttner audio interview with Gareth Cliff 12 March 2015


Launch of Recovering democracy in SA at the Troyeville Hotel


Raymond Suttner: Parliamentary upheavals: heightened political awareness? (Polity video)

Raymond Suttner: Citizens need to claim ethical leadership (English version Beeld article)

[Extract from Recovering Democracy, translated and printed in today’s Beeld, below] Continue reading